The quest for modernity for a Godless Utopia
IT Books-In-Brief Series
The IIIT series is a valuable collection of the Institute's main publications written in a concise form, designed to give readers a basic understanding of the main contents of the original.
Written in a brief, easy-to-read format that saves time, these summaries offer a faithful and carefully written overview of the full publication, and we hope they will encourage readers to further explore the original.
Haggag Ali's study, A Mapping of the Secular Mind: The Quest for Modernity for a Godless Utopia, was published in full in 2013. The secular mind had a grand plan to define an earthly paradise, a utopia of the here and now, of a modern civilization governed by human reason, rationality, and the triumph of progress.
Ideals are one thing, while the means to achieve them are another.
Far from the clamor, freeing humanity from the "chains" of God and religion has proven to be no easy task.
A Mapping of the Secular Mind critically examines the issues of reason, rationality, and secular materialism to analyze how these mental perceptions, or ways of delineating the world, have influenced human interactions and sociological development. It does so by comparing and contrasting the ideas of Abdelwahab M. Elmessiri
(1938-2008), a leading Arab intellectual, and Zygmunt Bauman (1925), one of the world's most important sociologists. In recent decades, an emerging Western critique of modernity has inspired Muslim intellectuals to develop new ideas, images, terms, and concepts that establish their positions toward the trends of secular modernity, its transformations and consequences, and how it manipulates the perception of reality.
The book challenges the foundations of secular ideology by arguing that its aspirations have profoundly transformed human consciousness and the human sense of self, reducing it to a meaningless consumer creature, exhausted by the pursuit of fulfillment, and controlled by materialistic laws that govern physical phenomena. It also offers a darker thesis, [arguing] that fascist Germany and the eugenics movement were a form of social Darwinism carried to its logical consequences. These were not an aberration of the principles of modernity, Ali argues, but a coherent outcome of the modern worldview, with the seeds of self-destruction woven into the very fabric of philosophy.
Chapter One
Introduction
In recent decades, the Western critique of modernity has led Muslim intellectuals to develop new ideas, images, terms, and concepts that affirm their position toward the trends of secular modernity, its transformations and consequences. Modernity is usually equated with the high ideals of the Enlightenment, in particular the promise of nature, reason, and progress to establish a rational and progressive system. This perspective changed largely after World War II and the development of a highly sophisticated Western discourse of self-examination, enhanced by the works of the Frankfurt School. In his attempt to deconstruct the dominant perception of modernity, the Egyptian Muslim intellectual Abdelwahab Elmessiri (1938-2008) was able to benefit from this Western critical heritage. Elmessiri's critique of modernity can be seen as an attempt to islamize modernity, but ironically through Western critique itself. For almost four de-cades, Elmessiri was engaged in a philosophically oriented study of Western modernity and its relationship with Nazism and Zion-
ism. Elmessiri usually describes his stay in the United States, during two distinct periods (1963-69 / 1975-79), as the crucial moment that shaped his understanding of the transformation of Western modernity as a "paradigmatic sequence," which begins with solid rational materialism and ends with liquid non-rational materialism.' The 70s, however, were very important years for understanding Elmessiri's critique of modernity, because this period saw the rise of political Islam, which succeeded, after the Arab defeat by Israel in 1967, in filling the void left by the left-wing movements, by their rhetoric of technological progress, as well as by their idealistic discourse of Arab socialism, a discourse that was abused to justify the loss of political freedoms in exchange for the rhetoric of national development and technological progress. The years
:70 can be seen as the charismatic period of political Islam, which was embraced by many of the leading figures of the Egyptian left as a vehicle for popular protest and national liberatio2
n? In both discourses, Western and Arab, modernity is almost always correlated with the ideals of the Enlightenment, in particular with the promise of Reason and science to promote our human and social existence. Elmessiri refers to this understanding of modernity as "partial secularism," which he describes as "moral secularism" or
"humanistic secularism."3
According to Elmessiri, the acceptance of this moderate secularism as an integral part of pluralism is embraced by the main Islamic trend, which is supported by Fahmi Huwaidi, Yusuf al-Qaradawi, Mohammed Selim al-Awa, Abu al-Ela Madi, and Adel Husain (Egypt),
Rachid Ghannouchi (Tunisia), Taha Jabir Alalwani (Iraq), AbdulHa-mid AbuSulayman (Saudi Arabia), Azzam Tamimi (Palestine), Parviz
Manzur (Pakistan) and Ahmet Davutoglu (Turkey). This Islamic trend accepts the legitimacy of moderate secularism and the role of its supporters as partners in the political life of Islamic society.4 In
Dirasat Ma rifiyyah fi al-Hadäthah al-Gharbiyyah (Epistemological Studies in Western Modernity), Elmessiri's studies deconstruct the mainstream understanding of Western secular modernity and define it as "the use of science and technology without value." It is a form of global secularism that aims not only at the independence of science and technology from human subjectivity or the separation between State and Church, but at the "separation of all values (whether re-ligious, moral, human), not only 'from the state', but also from public and private life, and from the world in general. In other words, it strives for the creation of a world devoid of values. "6
In the introduction to the third edition of Al-Subyüniyyah wa al-
Naziyyah wa Nihayat al -Tarikh (Zionism, Nazism and the End of History), dedicated to the French ex-Marxist intellectual Roger Garaudy, Elmessiri expresses his astonishment that before the late year
'80s Western scholars had barely recognized or associated Nazism and Zionism with the framework of a value-free, rationalistic, and imperialistic modernity. Elmessiri, however, is lavish with praise for Zygmunt Bauman's interpretation of modernity, asserting that his writings, particularly Modernity and the Holocaust (1989), are among the most important references from which he drew to develop his cognitive mapping of modernity."