The crisis of the Muslim mind
What is the human being? What is the mind? What is divine Revelation? How can the Muslim mind’s capacity to ask scientific and experimental “how” questions be restored while remaining consistent with the awareness that the universe has a Creator?”
Introduction:
Is there really a substantial difference between, on the one hand, the mind of someone who draws from the wellspring of secularism, sees through lenses borrowed from elsewhere, and whose cultural veins are coursed by philosophical currents closed off from scientific proof, and, on the other hand, the minds of other people? Is mental makeup the same for all human beings, whether they are educated and cultured or more or less illiterate? As for Revelation, psychologists and Orientalists have discussed it and classified it among paranormal pathological phenomena. I have not put psychologists in quotation marks, as this is a general reference to the deception of the jâhiliya, which is convinced that it has a scientific basis for its incoherent ramblings. Believing men and women, however, possess what can guide them away from the ramblings of the deaf and blind secular mind, which, like a bat, crashes into the light of Revelation and loses its bearings all the more. Believers have at their disposal the Book of God the Most High, the Creator of the human being, He who fashioned their faculties and guides whom He wills onto the right path. This is where the peculiarity of the believing mind begins, and its substantial difference from the mind common to all human beings, from the speculative, self-sufficient, deified mind, from the secular mind that organizes worldly affairs and is veiled to the reality of the Unseen (ghayb), for it does not listen to Revelation nor perceive its light. It is not a matter of one mind believing and receiving from God on the one hand, and the secular mind on the other. It is, rather, a substantial difference, not a matter of classification, for which the secular, philosophical mind is above or below the believing mind in terms of wisdom and intelligence. Rather, it is a qualitative difference. The secular, scientific mind finds ample room in thought and logical consideration regarding the cosmological realm. But when it attempts to understand what lies beyond its purview, it loses itself in the oceans of philosophy, hypotheses, and speculation. Unless this mind is rescued by divine mercy, which saves it from its straying and brings it back to the threshold of the fitra (the natural state), where the illiterate man, remaining in his fitra intact and uncontaminated by his parents and society, finds himself on the same level as the philosopher returned from his mental wanderings and speculations. The threshold of the fitra is, quite simply, the necessity of every creature for a Creator. It is a primary intuition of the human mind that philosophy demolishes and then dumps into the heap of suppositions, so that the secular mind, afflicted by intuitive blindness, is ready to foolishly accept the idea that it created itself. Darwin, the great philosopher, developed his theory and built his dogma by visiting the Galapagos Islands, where he was a student of a nature that had remained isolated from the continent for millions of years and had developed for itself its own model of life, which maintained its fauna and flora; “it developed for itself,” according to his presumption and blindness. The land iguana evolved, over different eras, by developing a pair of large lungs so that it could dive into the sea and feed on marine plants when land plants were scarce. Over long eras, the giant tortoise, the lady of the Galapagos, developed a lifestyle and means of subsistence that adapted to its natural environment. The tortoise gave its name to the islands: Galapago in Spanish means, precisely, tortoise. What had this clever animal done with itself? Over the eras, it developed for itself a long neck to reach the branches of plants that are usually out of reach for tortoises. Darwin sat on the back of the tortoise, his teacher, and the doctrine of evolution was revealed to him, which he later presented to the world. Then, investigating the continents, their plains and their mountains, their deserts and their fertile regions, he observed that the law of evolution is common to nature: that it builds itself, develops for its members limbs and organs that adapt to the constantly evolving environment. This applies to the iguanas and tortoises of the Galapagos, the insects of the desert, and the whales of the ocean. This also applies to the ape, which gradually evolved until it stood upright. It used stone tools and developed its mind, enlarged its skull, increased the weight of its brain, its intelligence grew remarkably, it lost its hair, straightened its nose, straightened its body, pronounced words with grunts after gestures, then used a tongue and later more languages, and finally developed science and philosophy. In this way, the philosophizing secular mind runs in a closed circle, having shut every window and blocked every channel, blinded its eyes and plugged its ears to the listening of Revelation.
by Abdessalam Yassine
(translated by Brahim Baya)
116 pages